How to make Sorbets
Sorbets are typically made of simple syrup (water and sugar) and suitable flavouring. As with other ice creams, air also needs to be incorporated in the base mixture to avoid rock-solid end results. Sorbets normally do not contain any dairy products, and without the fat these contain, the challenge is usually to keep down the size of the ice crystals. As with ordinary ice cream, large ice crystals will affect the texture negatively, away from the desired “smooth” and closer to the undesired “icy”. We will also take a quick look at sorbets made only with fruit purée and sugar (no simple sugar).
The main keys to success? Enough, but not too much, sugar, and fast freezing!
The overall sugar content and the basic sugar syrup
Since sorbets can be made on many different things (sweet fruits, more sour fruits, wines of differing sweetness …), some serious makers would insist on matching the proportions (sugar/water-ratio) to the specific fruit (or other flavouring) to be used. For that reason, it is difficult to give one “universal” sorbet recipe: just the sugar in the sugar syrup will typically not be enough, and adjustments will depend on what kind of sorbet you are making: dates have a natural sugar content of about 65 %, limes one of about 3 % = why you ideally should find a way to measure the overall sugar content of your sorbet base, which in the end ideally should contain about 25-35 % overall sugar.
Serious sorbet-making should therefore preferably use a special instrument to check the sugar content of the syrup. One such instrument is the refractometer, which measures the level of sweetness on a so-called Brix (°Bx) scale. Also used is the density measuring Baumé hydrometer, using the so-called Baumé scale. As per the above, a sorbet mixture (at least fruit-based ones) should keep about 17-18 °Baumé / 30-31 °Brix.
Why? If the sorbet mixture is too sweet, the level of sugar will prevent the sorbet from freezing properly. If the level of sugar is too low, however, the sorbet will freeze too hard, and the flavour is likely to taste “watered down”. Also with regard to the flavour, remember that the un-frozen base should taste somewhat sweeter than you would like, since the cold will dull the sensation of sweetness experienced in the final sorbet.
A mix of equal parts of water and sugar will give you a basic simple syrup to start with.
That said, I have seen some who have suggested a 65 % sugar/35 % water simple sugar syrup, which – I suppose – probably is intended to bring the sugar content closer to the final overall one, since most fruit sorbets will require more than what the sugar syrup alone can provide. What matters in the end is, however, the overall sugar content of the sorbet.
If you would like to minimise experimentation but still want to be serious about sugar levels (but not serious, or rich, enough to buy special instruments to check it), I will pass on an old kitchen trick: the Egg test.
An alternative take on making sorbets: Sorbets made with fruit purée and no sugar syrup
While this post focuses on “classic” sorbets made out of flavour and sugar syrup, there are other ways to make sorbet:
It is possible to make sorbets without any sugar syrup if the water content of the rest of the ingredients is high enough and sugar is added to the fruit purée: fruit sorbets are prime examples – go here for a delicious Strawberry sorbet made with this method!
Sorbets made this way – basically by mixing fruit purée and sugar – tend to melt quicker than “traditional” sorbet (since they contain less water), but often make up for this by offering fuller and rich(er) flavour experience. Just keep in mind that you still need to add sugar in case you want to have a sorbet, rather than just a chunk of frozen fruit purée.
The Egg test – estimate sugar levels without using special instruments
This test only requires a fresh egg. On the web, I have seen it well explained by Jenni Field. Basically, you drop the fresh egg (wash it first!) into the mixture. Watch carefully how much of the egg is showing up above the surface once it has resurfaced. If the egg remains submerged, or if less than about a scant 2 1/2 cm is showing above the surface, add more sugar. Likewise, if more than 2 1/2 cm is showing up, add more juice, fruit puree or water to the mixture.
When the “ideal” 2 1/2 cm elevation is achieved, this should translate into the likewise ideal 17-18 °Baumé!
(Why use fresh eggs? When eggs become older, they begin to contain more and more air. Eventually, an old egg would begin to float almost regardless of sugar content, which would render the Egg test rather worthless)
How to actually create the simple sugar syrup
There are basically two ways of preparing simple sugar syrup.
Cooking the water and sugar together seems to be the traditional, generally suggested option in most ice cream literature I have come across. Simmering the water and sugar for about five minutes is usually enough to create the viscous blend you want (see below for a chemical explanation of why sugar syrup is something more than just an uncomplicated mixture of water and sugar …).
However, there is also the much speedier way (let us call it the Hurried bartender’s method) which also tend to work quite well, and which does not require any cooling down: Simply mix water and sugar together without any heating. Whisk/stir/shake until all the sugar has dissolved. Voilà – ready to use! Obviously, if you do not find this solution ‘syrupy’ enough, do simmer the mixture!
Extra reading – Sugar syrup chemistry
What happens when sugar (sucrose) mixes with water? Chemically speaking, the weak bonds between the individual sucrose molecules are broken, and they are released into the water. Strong hydrogen bonds are created between the water and the sugar molecules, which is very good for sorbets: The sugar molecules not only increase the resulting syrup’s capacity to bind water (obviously super-important for avoiding unwanted iciness and improving texture) and offer sweetness – they also lower the freezing point (increases scoopability) and increase the shelf life. The process is greatly speeded up by heating, which is probably why boiling sugar syrup is the traditionally preferred method.
To add to the complexity, there are different types of sugars. And they all affect sorbets (and ice creams) differently. This and most other posts on this website assumes the use of “ordinary” white sugar (sucrose). However, those who wish to explore ice cream chemistry further will soon realise that mixing in other types (glucose, fructose, dextrose, maltodextrin …) can have profound effects. Most of these sugars adds less sweetness but are more effective in controlling crystallisation and depressing the freezing point than sucrose: in other words, their use can make the sorbet come out softer and creamier/less icy-feeling but without making them overly sweet (compared to the hefty amounts of sucrose required to affect the consistency in the same way).
Glucose- and Corn Syrup: consistency helpers
Glucose syrup and corn syrup are both examples of so-called inverted sugars. I mention them here because they are often used to improve on sorbets, quite accessible and easy to use. Their impact on consistency is more powerful than ordinary sucrose, allowing for an overall softer and “creamier” sorbet that still doesn’t taste overly sweet (as would have been the case if sucrose would be added to similar effect). Many sorbet makers swear by the addition of any of these inverted sugars, and those interested could well test to see what happens if, say, about 100 ml (around 1/2 cup) of the white sugar is replaced by these syrups. I personally often add 1-2 tablespoons of glucose- or corn syrup to my sorbet bases: even a small amount can go a long way.
A syrup, once made, can be stored in a bottle or closed jar in the refrigerator for about 2-3 weeks. When the syrup starts to become cloudy, it is about to begin to mold and should be discarded.
Base recipe – Sorbet
- Prepare a simple sugar syrup with equal parts water and sugar, like 500 ml (2 cups) water and 500 ml (2 cups) sugar. Since the sugar will dissolve, this should net you about 800 ml (about 3.4 cups) of simple sugar syrup.
- [If you would like to try the “sugar-elevated” 65/35 simple syrup instead, mix 525 ml (2,2 cups) sugar and 275 ml (1.16 cup) water.]
- If you cook the syrup (about 5 minutes of simmering, or less, should do), let it cool down before proceeding further.
- Mix the cooled down syrup with an equal volume of berries- or fruit purée/fruit juice + the specific additional sugar to match these and reach the desired overall sugar content for sorbets.
- In order to avoid an otherwise overly sweet sorbet, consider adding the juice of 1 lemon to the base.
- Freeze according to the instructions of your ice cream machine. If you do not have an ice cream machine, still-freeze in your freezer (go here for more exact instructions).
- Before freezing the mixture, consider adding 1-2 tablespoons of inverted sugar (such as corn syrup or glucose syrup), in order to ensure that the sorbet won’t freeze too solid and stay nice and soft(er). You could soften a sorbet up with a little bit of alcohol too, but go carefully – too much, and the mixture might never freeze.
UPDATE: For MORE WAYS TO IMPROVE SORBETS not covered above, check out this general post on various ways to make them better and last longer in the freezer, this post devoted to the particular, classic method of adding so-called Italian meringue and the more modern method of adding Aquafaba meringue: both methods guaranteed to take your sorbets to new heights 😉